10 Best Real Estate Agents in New York, NY (2026)
Quick Comparison
| Rank | Business | Rating | Reviews | Price | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Professional Realty SoHo | ★ 5 | 112 | $$$$ | Quality |
| #2 | Trusted Realty Astoria | ★ 4.8 | 387 | $$ | Quality |
| #3 | Prestige Realty Williamsburg | ★ 4.7 | 432 | $$ | Value |
| #4 | Urban Real Estate Manhattan | ★ 4.7 | 113 | $ | Value |
| #5 | Top Agents Bronx | ★ 4.6 | 490 | $$$$ | Reliable Service |
| #6 | Prime Realty Williamsburg | ★ 4.5 | 142 | $$ | Value |
| #7 | Metro Properties Staten Island | ★ 4.3 | 429 | $$$$ | Reliable Service |
| #8 | City Real Estate Staten Island | ★ 4.1 | 381 | $$$$ | Reliable Service |
| #9 | Elite Properties SoHo | ★ 3.8 | 284 | $$$ | Reliable Service |
| #10 | Premier Homes Bronx | ★ 3.6 | 228 | $$$$ | Reliable Service |
Detailed Rankings
Professional Realty SoHo
📍 5498 Oak St, SoHo, NY 76619
💰 $$$$
🕒 Mon-Fri 9AM-6PM
"Friendly staff and excellent service. Will return for sure." — Amanda K.
Trusted Realty Astoria
📍 2571 Elm St, Astoria, NY 48798
💰 $$
🕒 Mon-Sun 10AM-10PM
"Had some issues with scheduling and communication." — John K.
Prestige Realty Williamsburg
📍 2531 Main St, Williamsburg, NY 37293
💰 $$
🕒 Mon-Fri 7AM-7PM, Sat-Sun 9AM-5PM
"Professional, courteous, and efficient. Highly recommended." — Ashley T.
Urban Real Estate Manhattan
📍 2775 Park Ave, Manhattan, NY 70436
💰 $
🕒 Mon-Sun 10AM-10PM
"Absolutely fantastic service! Highly recommend." — Jennifer B.
Top Agents Bronx
📍 7733 Maple Dr, Bronx, NY 99981
💰 $$$$
🕒 Open 24/7
"Outstanding service from start to finish." — Daniel D.
Prime Realty Williamsburg
📍 1214 Elm St, Williamsburg, NY 94037
💰 $$
🕒 Mon-Fri 7AM-7PM, Sat-Sun 9AM-5PM
"Solid service. Would consider coming back." — Chris L.
Metro Properties Staten Island
📍 3364 Main St, Staten Island, NY 56476
💰 $$$$
🕒 Mon-Sun 10AM-10PM
"Solid service. Would consider coming back." — Sarah H.
City Real Estate Staten Island
📍 5359 Washington Blvd, Staten Island, NY 14212
💰 $$$$
🕒 Mon-Fri 7AM-7PM, Sat-Sun 9AM-5PM
"Impressive quality and attention to customer needs." — David H.
Elite Properties SoHo
📍 9926 Market St, SoHo, NY 84157
💰 $$$
🕒 Open 24/7
"Had some issues with scheduling and communication." — Jessica T.
Premier Homes Bronx
📍 9771 Broadway, Bronx, NY 33703
💰 $$$$
🕒 Open 24/7
"Good service overall. A few minor issues but nothing major." — David K.
How We Ranked These Real Estate Agents
Our ranking methodology combines quantitative and qualitative factors to identify the best real estate agents in New York. We analyze customer ratings (weighted 40%), review volume and recency (30%), service quality indicators from review content (20%), and business information accuracy (10%). This data-driven approach ensures our rankings reflect genuine customer experiences rather than paid placements or advertising.
Tips for Choosing a real estate agent in New York
Best Real Estate Agents by Neighborhood
Williamsburg
2 Real Estate Agents
Average Rating: 4.6 ★
Top Pick: Prestige Realty Williamsburg (4.7 ★)
Staten Island
2 Real Estate Agents
Average Rating: 4.2 ★
Top Pick: Metro Properties Staten Island (4.3 ★)
Frequently Asked Questions
How do we rank Real Estate Agents in New York?
We use a data-driven methodology analyzing customer ratings (40% weight), review volume and recency (30%), service quality indicators (20%), and business information accuracy (10%). Our rankings are based on publicly available data and are not influenced by advertising or paid placements.
What makes a real estate agent highly rated in New York?
Top-rated real estate agents consistently demonstrate excellent customer service, professional expertise, transparent pricing, and reliable availability. They maintain high ratings across numerous reviews, indicating sustained quality over time.
How often are these rankings updated?
We update our New York Real Estate Agents rankings regularly as new reviews and ratings become available. However, we recommend verifying current hours, pricing, and availability directly with the business before visiting.
Are these reviews verified?
All reviews are sourced from public business listings where customers have left verified feedback. We aggregate this publicly available data to provide comprehensive rankings.
Can businesses pay to be ranked higher?
No. Our rankings are based solely on customer ratings, reviews, and service quality data. We do not accept payment for rankings or placements.