10 Best Auto Repair in New York, NY (2026)

Finding the right auto repair in New York can be challenging with so many options available. We've analyzed 10 auto repair across New York, NY, examining 1,847 customer reviews to bring you this comprehensive ranking. Our evaluation process considers multiple factors: customer ratings, review volume, service quality feedback, pricing, and location convenience. These auto repair represent the top options in New York, with ratings averaging 3.8 stars. New York's diverse neighborhoods each offer unique advantages for auto repair services. From Manhattan's premium options to Brooklyn's community-focused establishments, our rankings help you find the perfect match for your needs and location.

Quick Comparison

Rank	Business	Rating	Reviews	Price	Best For
#1	Precision Auto Astoria	★ 4.1	97	$$$	Reliable Service
#2	Expert Auto Care Upper East Side	★ 4	306	$$$	Reliable Service
#3	Trusted Auto Shop Staten Island	★ 4	218	$$$$	Reliable Service
#4	City Auto Repair Williamsburg	★ 3.8	346	$$$$	Reliable Service
#5	Reliable Auto Manhattan	★ 3.7	360	$$	Value
#6	Auto Care Center Bronx	★ 3.7	219	$$$$	Reliable Service
#7	Quick Fix Auto SoHo	★ 3.6	128	$$$$	Reliable Service
#8	Elite Auto Service Astoria	★ 3.5	129	$$$	Reliable Service
#9	Pro Auto Repair Brooklyn	★ 3.9	22	$$$$	Reliable Service
#10	Master Mechanics SoHo	★ 3.6	22	$$$$	Reliable Service

Detailed Rankings

Precision Auto Astoria

★ 4.1 (97 reviews)

📍 6028 Washington Blvd, Astoria, NY 10291

📞 (435) 337-5941

💰 $$$

🕒 Mon-Sun 10AM-10PM

"Top-notch quality. Will definitely be coming back." — Chris D.

Read Full Review Visit Website

Expert Auto Care Upper East Side

★ 4 (306 reviews)

📍 5906 Washington Blvd, Upper East Side, NY 32600

📞 (921) 405-3481

💰 $$$

🕒 Mon-Sun 10AM-10PM

"Impressive quality and attention to customer needs." — Emily B.

Read Full Review Visit Website

Trusted Auto Shop Staten Island

★ 4 (218 reviews)

📍 8329 Main St, Staten Island, NY 93411

📞 (258) 401-1210

💰 $$$$

🕒 Mon-Fri 9AM-6PM

"Average experience. Nothing special but not bad either." — Amanda R.

Read Full Review Visit Website

City Auto Repair Williamsburg

★ 3.8 (346 reviews)

📍 9589 Market St, Williamsburg, NY 87591

📞 (538) 661-7619

💰 $$$$

🕒 Mon-Sun 10AM-10PM

"Best experience I've had in years. Professional and friendly staff." — John K.

Read Full Review Visit Website

Reliable Auto Manhattan

★ 3.7 (360 reviews)

📍 4704 Maple Dr, Manhattan, NY 85918

📞 (342) 903-8892

💰 $$

🕒 Open 24/7

"Exceeded my expectations. Great attention to detail." — Robert S.

Read Full Review Visit Website

Auto Care Center Bronx

★ 3.7 (219 reviews)

📍 3071 Main St, Bronx, NY 63041

📞 (475) 856-3439

💰 $$$$

🕒 Mon-Fri 9AM-6PM

"Outstanding service from start to finish." — Amanda L.

Read Full Review Visit Website

Quick Fix Auto SoHo

★ 3.6 (128 reviews)

📍 3333 Maple Dr, SoHo, NY 79016

📞 (494) 230-7716

💰 $$$$

🕒 Mon-Fri 9AM-6PM

"Best experience I've had in years. Professional and friendly staff." — Lisa S.

Read Full Review Visit Website

Elite Auto Service Astoria

★ 3.5 (129 reviews)

📍 6274 Elm St, Astoria, NY 50369

📞 (883) 909-9232

💰 $$$

🕒 Mon-Fri 7AM-7PM, Sat-Sun 9AM-5PM

"Fair pricing and reasonable quality." — Jessica T.

Read Full Review Visit Website

Pro Auto Repair Brooklyn

★ 3.9 (22 reviews)

📍 6992 Broadway, Brooklyn, NY 93309

📞 (610) 202-8593

💰 $$$$

🕒 Open 24/7

"Top-notch quality. Will definitely be coming back." — Robert H.

Read Full Review Visit Website

#10

Master Mechanics SoHo

★ 3.6 (22 reviews)

📍 7534 Main St, SoHo, NY 47181

📞 (960) 455-1981

💰 $$$$

🕒 Open 24/7

"Fair pricing and reasonable quality." — Emily D.

Read Full Review Visit Website

How We Ranked These Auto Repair

Our ranking methodology combines quantitative and qualitative factors to identify the best auto repair in New York. We analyze customer ratings (weighted 40%), review volume and recency (30%), service quality indicators from review content (20%), and business information accuracy (10%). This data-driven approach ensures our rankings reflect genuine customer experiences rather than paid placements or advertising.

Read our full ranking methodology →

Tips for Choosing a auto repair in New York

When selecting a auto repair in New York, consider these key factors: **Location and Accessibility** - Choose a provider convenient to your home or work. Check subway and bus access if you rely on public transportation. **Ratings and Reviews** - Look for consistent positive feedback across multiple reviews, not just high star counts. **Pricing Transparency** - Quality auto repair services should provide clear pricing information upfront. **Availability** - Confirm their hours match your schedule, especially if you need evening or weekend appointments. **Specializations** - Some auto repair specialize in specific services or customer types. Read reviews to understand their strengths.

Best Auto Repair by Neighborhood

Astoria

2 Auto Repair
Average Rating: 3.8 ★

Top Pick: Precision Auto Astoria (4.1 ★)

SoHo

2 Auto Repair
Average Rating: 3.6 ★

Top Pick: Quick Fix Auto SoHo (3.6 ★)

Upper East Side

1 Auto Repair
Average Rating: 4.0 ★

Top Pick: Expert Auto Care Upper East Side (4 ★)

Staten Island

1 Auto Repair
Average Rating: 4.0 ★

Top Pick: Trusted Auto Shop Staten Island (4 ★)

Williamsburg

1 Auto Repair
Average Rating: 3.8 ★

Top Pick: City Auto Repair Williamsburg (3.8 ★)

Frequently Asked Questions

How do we rank Auto Repair in New York?

We use a data-driven methodology analyzing customer ratings (40% weight), review volume and recency (30%), service quality indicators (20%), and business information accuracy (10%). Our rankings are based on publicly available data and are not influenced by advertising or paid placements.

What makes a auto repair highly rated in New York?

Top-rated auto repair consistently demonstrate excellent customer service, professional expertise, transparent pricing, and reliable availability. They maintain high ratings across numerous reviews, indicating sustained quality over time.

How often are these rankings updated?

We update our New York Auto Repair rankings regularly as new reviews and ratings become available. However, we recommend verifying current hours, pricing, and availability directly with the business before visiting.

Are these reviews verified?

All reviews are sourced from public business listings where customers have left verified feedback. We aggregate this publicly available data to provide comprehensive rankings.

Can businesses pay to be ranked higher?

No. Our rankings are based solely on customer ratings, reviews, and service quality data. We do not accept payment for rankings or placements.